32 Of The Most Amazing Unicorn Cakes You Will Love - Agoralia Recipes (2024)

Get the best ideas for unicorn cakes from our list. We have everything from beautiful rainbow unicorn cakes to simple smash cakes!

Are you looking for ideas to make unicorn cakes at home? Then look at our list, which features different unicorn cakes for all occasions. The recipes on the list also have different levels of skills, so whether you’re a beginner decorator or an expert, there’s something for everyone.

We’ve created four different types of unicorn cake recipe lists: rainbow unicorn cakes, unicorn ice cream cakes, unicorn smash cakes, and pink unicorn cakes. So go ahead and pick one that suits your taste the most, and let us know how everything goes!

Here’s one of the most beautiful unicorn rainbow cakes that your little ones will love. When you cut into this unicorn layer cake, you’ll see a myriad of rainbow colors adorning the inside of the cake.

This cake has six different layers, each corresponding to the rainbow’s colors. You start with red, orange, yellow, green, blue, and purple. What’s great about this cake is that you’ll only have to prepare one vanilla sponge cake batter, then you can put in some food coloring to create the layers.

You’ll make the unicorn horn, ears, and eyes with marshmallow fondant. You’ll also cover the cake with buttercream to create the mane. Truly one of the best girly unicorn birthday cakes ever.

Do you want to make a happy birthday unicorn cake that’s impressive but easy to make? Then why not try this recipe when you have the time? This easy unicorn birthday cake recipe uses white velvet buttermilk cake, rainbow buttercream mane, pretty sprinkles, edible pearls, and a gold unicorn horn.

Just like the previous recipe, you’ll also see a beautiful rainbow pattern inside the cake. But instead of having stacks of colors, the rainbow will be a tie-dye style that goes throughout the sponge cake.

Another plus point from the recipe is that they have printable eyes that you can stick onto the cake! This recipe is one of the best unicorn-themed cake recipes on our list, and you should try it when you have the time!

Calories per serving: 823
Total Preparation Time: 40 minutes

If you want to make simple unicorn cakes, then this recipe is one that you have to try. This cake is a DIY, easy unicorn-themed cake recipe you can bake and decorate at home.

It’s the perfect choice for your next birthday party, and we guarantee it will be popular with the little ones. Although most of you might feel it’s appropriate for birthdays, you can also use it for baby showers because it has a whimsical and adorable feel.

The unicorn horn and ears toppers are from a pack of unicorn-themed cake toppers, and the eyes are from printables. You have to create the base cake and then pipe on the buttercream mane, and you’ve got unique cake designs.

Do you want to become an experienced baker but dread making your own cake from scratch? Then you don’t have to worry about this easy DIY unicorn cake because the maker explicitly uses a box cake to create the base of this pretty cake!

You will love how they make unicorn sheet cakes into something impressive looking. The secret to making your box cake mix better is substituting the water with milk and oil with butter.

They also decided to add another egg to the batter so that it had more moisture. This excellent tutorial contains valuable tips that can tell you how to make a unicorn-themed cake better.

Total Preparation Time: 2 hours 30 minutes

If you’re looking for cake ideas and want to make your cake from scratch, make this recipe for unicorn cakes for girls. The maker of this tutorial is not only helpful, but she’ll take you step by step through the process.

You start by creating the fluffy vanilla funfetti base cake, then cool them for about an hour. Stack them to create a tall cake, and start decorating your unicorn theme cake. You will need five bags of different icing colors to create the mane and the eyes.

You will also need some white fondant to make the ears and horns. Lastly, you will dust it using an edible gold highlighter. It’s not an easy birthday cake unicorn, but it’s worth it.

Do you want easy unicorn cakes to make for your next birthday celebration? This recipe is similar to the baby unicorn-themed cake trend that is showing up on social media, so it might look familiar to you.

This cake has a beautifully moist chocolate sponge cake, but you can switch the flavors if you’re not into it. Before putting them onto the cake, you will also create the ears and horn using fondant and edible gold.

Cover the cake with white buttercream, then start piping on a colorful buttercream mane. Finish off the cake with black icing to draw on his eyes, and you have a great birthday cake.

Do you want to bake a unicorn-themed cake but need more confidence to do it yourself? Then it would be best if you tried this easy unicorn cake recipe that uses a box cake. It’s easy to bake, and you can easily double the recipe.

You will need two boxes of vanilla sponge cakes for this cake because you want to create six different layers of the rainbow. Then mix the food coloring into the batter, and bake the sponge cakes.

Chill for several hours, then decorate using some buttercream. You will need purple, pink, and red buttercream to create a flower and mane effect for the unicorn. Top it off with fondant ears and a horn, and you’ve got a beautiful unicorn-themed cake.

If the six-layer cakes we have on this list seem overwhelming, then this rainbow cake is much more beginner-friendly than the previous ones. You’ll only have to make four different layers of primary colors for this rainbow cake.

The colors are red, yellow, blue, and green. After that, the cake process is similar to the others. You will need to get the unicorn cake topper set, which has the horn, the ears, and the eyes.

Stick the toppers onto the cake, and then create the mane using colored buttercream. Take the cake to the next level by putting some edible flowers and pearls on top.

If you want a more colorful cake, then this recipe is something you can try making at home. This is an exceptional and colorful unicorn-themed cake, which is why it is dubbed the tie-dye rainbow unicorn cake.

This cake is unique because the base has bright rainbow colors, but the decorations are white. Start by making the base cake using your favorite sponge cake recipe. Then cover the cake using several shades of buttercream to create the tie-dye and rainbow effect.

Lastly, create the eyes and mane using white buttercream and the horn using white fondant. Put some edible rainbow pearls to top everything off.

Calories per serving: 646
Total Preparation Time: 2 hours 35 minutes

Is your little one a fan of candies? Then it would help if you made this rainbow unicorn cake with candy horns for their next birthday celebration. You start by baking the base cake; the maker uses vanilla sponge cake batter and then swirls in rainbow colors to make the cake have a tie-dye effect.

After that, you cover the cake with white buttercream. Prepare the decorations by making the ears using fondant and buying a rainbow candy stick.

Then pipe on the colorful mane using your kid’s favorite colors. Lastly, stick the horn and ears onto the cake and decorate it with pop rocks and edible pearls.

Calories per serving: 819
Total Preparation Time: 3 hours 30 minutes

If you want a more elegant unicorn cake, then this cake is something you have to try to make at home. The colors in this cake are very muted, making it look much more mature than others on this list.

The maker uses pastel colors, which you can create by mixing white with vibrant colors. The cake layers inside are also colored using pastel colors.

Make sure you don’t mix in too much food coloring to get the muted color effect. Stack the cake together, then cover it with white buttercream. Then create the horn using an ice cream cone dipped in funfetti or sprinkles.

Calories per serving: 274
Total Preparation Time: 57 minutes

If you have many guests coming to your party, try making this two-tier cake to feed everyone! This feminine unicorn cake is made by stacking two tiers of cake on top of each other.

You will decorate the bottom tier with a tie-dye buttercream rosette, and the top level will look like a unicorn’s head. Start by making two batches of your favorite base cake to have enough sponge cakes for two tiers.

You will create fondant horns and ears, then pipe on a colorful buttercream mane on top of the cake. Dip the horn and ears into edible gold dust to take the cake to the next level.

Do you want to make an effortless unicorn cake? Sometimes decorating a cake can be overwhelming; you need to look for more accessible alternatives like this. To make this cake, you don’t need decorating skills because it uses a printout topper.

The base cake is a straightforward round-layer cake covered in white buttercream. This creates a clean look that will delight everyone coming to your party.

To make the cake less plain, decorate the edges of your cake with blue buttercream and the middle of your cake with rainbow and heart marshmallow candies.

If six different colors are not enough, this recipe has eight different layers with distinctive colors! The result will be something that your kids will love, and all the effort you put into making this cake will be worth it.

To make this cake, you need to buy the unicorn cake topper set, which will give you the horn, ears, and colorful fake colors to liven up the cake. Cover the cake with white buttercream, then prepare pastel color icing to decorate the cake.

Make the mane from colorful pastel icing, and don’t forget to create the eyes using black buttercream. Lastly, create blushing cheeks using pink buttercream.

Total Preparation Time: 2 hours 15 minutes

If you’re not feeling like decorating or shaping a cake, this unicorn cake will resonate with all busy moms. This single-layer unicorn sheet cake is a delicious and moist cake known as unicorn poke cake.

It has a colorful sponge base cake, white buttercream icing, and colorful sprinkles on top of the cake. Start by creating the sponge cake using a box cake mix and food colorings. The colors in this cake are purple, pink, and blue, which are the typical unicorn colors.

This cake also has a filling that you make from pudding and milk. After that, cover the cake using white vanilla buttercream and sprinkle blue, pink, and purple sprinkles.

Calories per serving: 494

Here’s another recipe for a simple unicorn poke cake. This cake uses different colors and has a more fun feel than the last. The colors they use are yellow, blue, purple, and pink. Similar to the previous cake, this cake also has a filling made from vanilla pudding. You fill it by poking several holes into the cake and inserting the filling carefully, which is why people call this cake a poke cake! Wait until the wake is cooled off before poking them because they will disintegrate if you fill them while hot. Then, cover the cake using vanilla buttercream and top it off with colorful sprinkles.

Total Preparation Time: 40 minutes

Click below to see the recipe:

Do you want to make a unicorn ice cream cake just like Little Debbie unicorn cakes? This cake is a cute unicorn Kawaii ice cream cake that looks like an ice cream cone and has the features of a unicorn.

The top of the cake is a vanilla ice cream scoop with a white unicorn horn and a colorful unicorn mane that you make using fondant. The bottom tier is an ice cream cone you make using beige fondant.

Other decorative elements on this cake are the unicorn’s ears, eyes, mouth, and little wings. You can create all of these elements using colored fondants. The result is a cute cake that adults and kids won’t resist.

Are you looking for a homemade version of the Dairy Queen unicorn ice cream cake? This copycat recipe is just as good, if not better than the Dairy Queen version. This recipe is straightforward.

All you need is vanilla ice cream, chocolate ice cream, a pack of Oreo cookies, and two jars of fudge. You will also need to buy the unicorn cake topper set that has a horn, ears, and flowers. Because it’s an ice cream cake, you will need more time to make it.

You will shape the cake, then leave it to freeze. That’s why it’s best to start making this cake the day before, freeze it, and present it. It’s a simple cake, but it also needs some preparation time.

Calories per serving: 544

If you want a simple unicorn ice cream cake, try making this purple and pink unicorn ice cream cake. To say it’s a whole ice cream cake is a bit misleading; this is a mixed cake with two sponge cakes and one ice cream.

You will bake a rainbow chip mix cake, chill it, and stack it with unicorn ice cream. You can use any other in-store flavors if you don’t have the unicorn ice cream flavor.

After that, you will cover the cake with frozen whipped topping, then decorate the cake with colorful buttercream to create the mane. Lastly, buy a unicorn face kit and decorate your cake.

Do you want a simple-looking cake that doesn’t have the shape of a unicorn but still has its unique colors? This recipe will give you a fantastic unicorn cake that still has its essence without being over the top with the design.

The cake is a simple single-tier ice cream cake with unicorn colors and sprinkles. Although it looks simple, this cake needs a lot of effort. You will make your ice cream because you want all those beautiful colors inside the cake’s layers.

Aside from the ice cream, you will also bake the base for the cake using vanilla sponge cakes. Try this if you ever want to make your ice cream; no ice cream machine is needed!

Calories per serving: 216.9

Here’s another straightforward recipe for unicorn ice cream cake that you can easily make at home. Unlike the previous recipe, you won’t have to make the ice cream from scratch. Start by baking your vanilla sponge cake, then chill it for a couple of hours.

When it’s cool, scoop out rainbow ice cream and sandwich it between the sponge cakes. The cake is made to look like a log, so you will need to cut the sponge cake accordingly.

Cool the cake, so the ice cream is hardened, then start covering the cake using colorful buttercream. To make this cake unicorn themed, they used pink, teal, and purple as colors. Lastly, put the sugar cone on top of the cake to look like a horn.

Total Preparation Time: 2 hours 20 minutes

Creating a baby unicorn cake or a unicorn smash cake is always fun. Smash cakes are designed to celebrate a baby’s first birthday, and the baby can do whatever it wants with the cake.

More often than not, they will smash the cake, where the cake gets its name. This smash cake is straightforward; it’s a single-layer small cake decorated with buttercream and a unicorn topper set.

The buttercream has different colors – pink, blue, purple, and yellow. You can use any colors that will be suitable for your baby. The maker also puts in a jam between the cake to create a filling, but if you want to, you can skip this step.

If you want a more subtle unicorn design, this giant unicorn cupcake cake will be a suitable recipe. The cake looks like a giant cupcake, with colorful rosettes on top of its cupcake wrapper. You will also decorate the cake using horns and ears.

Unlike another recipe, you will create your own horn and ears for this recipe. Use gray fondant to make the ears and horn, then layer the fondant with edible silver dust. You can use white fondant and edible gold dust if you prefer gold.

To make the cupcake shape, you will bake vanilla sponge cakes and then shape them to look like a cupcake. It’s the perfect smash cake for your little ones, who will love colorful flowers.

Are you a busy mom looking for more straightforward unicorn smash cake recipes? Then look no further because this cake is one of the most straightforward recipes on this list.

This smash cake is a single-tier cake with plain white buttercream and sprinkles as decoration. The maker also put a toy unicorn on the cake, making it the perfect tiny unicorn smash cake.

Typically you want to spend less time on smash cakes because the baby will destroy the cake when we give it to them. That’s why this is the perfect recipe for a smash cake. Effortless, easy, and fun, this cake still has all the essential design elements but without the hassle.

Total Preparation Time: 30 minutes

A first birthday only comes once, and you should want to make your little one’s first birthday special. This unicorn smash cake has a beautiful design, similar to the entire size cake we have on this list.

Start by baking your vanilla sponge cake to create the base cake. Then stack them together to make a single-tier cake. Decorate the cake with white buttercream icing, then stick it on the unicorn cake toppers you can get from the store.

After that, you will be piping different buttercream colors onto the cake to create the mane. Finish the cake with sprinkles, and let your baby enjoy it.

This unicorn smash cake is straightforward but still looks impressive with gradient colors on its sides. It’s the perfect smash cake. You want it to be easy and quick because your baby will smash it in the next minute.

Start by baking your cake mix, the maker chooses a funfetti cake mix, but you can switch it with anything you prefer. Then use buttercream icing to stack the layers together, and cover the cake with white buttercream.

Then you use food coloring to create pink, blue, and purple icing and slather it on top of the white icing to make the color gradient. Lastly, put the cake toppers on top of the cake, and you’re ready with your smash cake.

Do you want a monochrome color unicorn cake? Then this feminine pink unicorn-themed cake with roses and leaves is the perfect cake to bake for your next celebration. The cake has light pink colors, pink eras, red horn, and roses as its mane.

Start by baking your base cake. The maker chooses funfetti vanilla sponge cake but switches this to anything you prefer. Then you stack them together with pink buttercream icing in between.

Then cover the cake with light pink buttercream icing, and create your unicorn horn and ears using pink fondant. Stick the fondant onto the cake, and decorate the cake using dark pink buttercream to create the mane.

Who wouldn’t love a unicorn cake design that looks like it’s also ready to party with its cute party hat? This is a simple pink unicorn-themed cake, but it has a cone party hat on top with colorful polka dots, making this a very festive-looking cake.

Start by baking your favorite base cake, then stack them together using buttercream frosting. After that, you will cover the cake using pink fondant to create the face’s background. Then you will make other face elements using fondant.

Lastly, you will create the party hat using foam board, cover the foam with pink fondant and decorate it with colorful polka dots. You can also trim the bottom edges with bright polka dots.

Here’s a charming pink unicorn cake idea you can try at home. The cake is a plain single-tier cake decorated with fondant and sour candy strips. Start by preparing your vanilla cake batter, then mix in pink food coloring into the batter.

Bake the cake and let it cool. Then cover the cake with white buttercream icing, and prepare your decorative elements using fondant. You will also make the unicorn horn using an ice cream cone and buttercream.

Put the parts on top of the cake and the sour candy stripes on the cake to create the unicorn’s mane. Remember to use pink candy sours because you want this cake to be entirely pink.

Are you a vegan and afraid of missing out on tasting delicious cakes? Then try this vegan pink unicorn cake recipe, and you’ll never look back. The cake is a simple single-tier cake with pink buttercream frosting, fondant horn, fondant ears, and an abundance of marshmallows.

The secret to this cake is switching the dairy ingredients with dairy-free options, such as coconut oil, almond milk, and dairy-free dark chocolate. Start by baking your base cake, the maker uses a vegan vanilla sponge cake recipe, but you can use anything you prefer as your base cake.

Then decorate the cake using dairy-free buttercream, and top it off with fondant decorations and vegan marshmallows.

Total Preparation Time: 35 minutes

Are you a beginner baker who wants to start your baking journey by making your first unicorn-themed cake? Then this beginner-friendly pink unicorn cake might be the recipe you’re looking for.

The cake is a single-tier cake made with a box of funfetti mix. It is decorated with homemade marshmallow fondant. You will make the fondant by mixing marshmallows, powdered sugar, and Crisco.

This fondant will cover the cake and also make the horn and ears. Stack the cake with strawberry frosting, then draw some eyes using black icing. Top the cake with the decorative elements you made from fondant earlier. Your cake is ready for the party.

Unicorn cake recipes don’t get simpler than this one. This cake is straightforward, and even beginner decorators will find it easy. The cake is a single-layer cake with buttercream icing decoration and a printout for its horn and ears.

The cake is so easy to make. The maker also bakes unicorn cupcakes to accompany it. Start by baking the base cake, the maker uses chocolate sponge cakes, but you can use any flavors you prefer.

Cool them, and then stack them together. Cover the cake with pink buttercream icing, and create the mane using the same colors. Have the horn and ears printouts ready, and stick them onto the cake using a skewer.

32 of the Most Amazing Unicorn Cakes You Will Love

Get the best ideas for unicorn cakes from our list. We have everything from beautiful rainbow unicorn cakes to simple smash cakes!

Tell us how we can improve this post?